Monday 25 March 2013

Drama in Malaysia, 2013

The season opening race in Australia did not have as much obvious action as we have been used to in the past but there was an intense feeling as teams and drivers tried to get to grips with this year’s Pirelli tyres in their first full race run. Teams do simulations in the winter testing but it is not a complete correlation. Malaysia’s tricky conditions proved to be a much sterner test and there was a lot more action to be seen in the second race.

Managing Track Conditions


Qualifying was a good example of the changeable conditions that can come about very quickly. The sessions started dry but ended wet. If the race was dry, it would mean the top ten could choose which tyres to start on. This time, the race started on a wet track and this resulted in Intermediate tyres being the starting choice. The initial period was a gamble of how long to stay out and when to pit for the slick tyres and then the different strategies started to come to light, especially in the Red bull team, with Mark Webber and Sebastian Vettel both opting for a different choice throughout the race.

Alonso’s Front Wing


Ferrari have said that the decision not to pit Fernando Alonso after he damaged his front wing on the first lap was that of the team and not the driver. I can’t understand why they thought the wing would survive. It was a risk, but if it was designed to have two supports, it surely was not going to survive on one, especially with the g-forces and speeds the cars were going at. Yes, they are meant to be robust but it baffles me. Pitting early (or making an extra stop as would have been the case) would have damaged his race but with the drives we have seen from Alonso last year in particular, he could have had a strong points finish rather than nothing at all.

Force India’s Pit Problems


I feel for Force India. They had a good pace all weekend to follow on from Melbourne last week and neither car managed to finish. The pit stop problems meant that the safety of the drivers in their team and the rest of the grid had to be considered. No matter how exciting a crash or incident may look, it isn’t safe and there was no other option if they were not absolutely certain that the cars were okay. They should have a strong season if they keep going along these lines, though.
 

McLaren’s Mixed Race


With only a week since the dismal performance of the McLaren cars in Austraila, the team seem to have made a good step forward. How much of that was down to track and good strategy we can’t really be sure but we have seen in the past how they can turn it around. Reminiscent of last year, a pit stop problem caused Jenson Button a problem and the eventual retirement followed. It’s a shame as they had a good haul of points to claim, possibly even a podium as Button’s pace was very good. If they can keep this up over the next three weeks before China, we might have a McLaren that can make an impact, albeit a late one, for the rest of the season. Sergio Perez had a reasonably quiet race but picked up two points. His pit stop at the end was strange but the team obviously thought it through and better safe than sorry.

Mercedes Finish Strong


It was a good result for Mercedes, with both drivers in the top four. There will be some tension within the team in the aftermath of the race. The team orders issue has been controversial in the past and so it will be this week. Lewis Hamilton and Nico Rosberg were both battling for third but after an order to control the race, they settled into their finishing positions. Rosberg was not happy about this, as his strategy meant he could have gone faster than Hamilton but team principal Ross Brawn was more concerned with the double points finish. Hamilton showed a lot of respect for Rosberg after the race but he took the points and it will be interesting to watch what happens in the team in the coming races.

Red Bull at it Again


We’ve seen on numerous occasions how ruthless Vettel can be when it comes to winning races. This has to be the most obvious example of that, and it cannot be swept under the carpet. How Webber kept his head as the two cars were wheel to wheel, I have no idea. The result for Christian Horner and the team was to have the one-two finish, which they got but Vettel was told hold behind his teammate. The post-race interviews showed how angry Webber was, and rightly so. This is racing, yes, but the team made a call and Vettel ignored it, no matter how you rephrase it. It was shocking behaviour from a sportsman but showed why he is a triple world champion.
 

Summary


I don’t agree with team orders this early in the season but I can understand trying to save fuel and engines. How much this mattered in the decision by the teams to control the end of the race, I don’t know. I don’t buy Vettel “not getting the message.” If he believed he was being told to not make silly moves, then he still disobeyed that by pushing so hard over a stream of corners. We don’t get all the radio messages through media coverage but it was clear that Webber was told he was going to be left to lead but for a disaster on the car. The two drivers have had a strained relationship over the years but it is coming to boiling point now. If Webber continues to race next year, it won’t be with Vettel as his teammate, and it’s hard to see Red Bull letting their champion go.

Lotus had a quiet race this weekend but they still got some good points. With the drama of team orders in Red Bull and Mercedes, a lot of the lower teams were forgotten. It is already shaping up to be an interesting season.

Results


1 – S. Vettel (Red Bull)

2 – M. Webber (Red Bull)

3 – L. Hamilton (Mercedes)

4 – N. Rosberg (Mercedes)

5 – F. Massa (Ferrari)

6 – R. Grosjean (Lotus)

7 – K. Raikkonen (Lotus)

8 – N. Hulkenberg (Sauber)

9 – S. Perez (McLaren)

10 – J. E. Vergne (Toro Rosso)

11 – V. Bottas (Williams)

12 – E. Gutierrez (Sauber)

13 – J. Bianchi (Marussia)

14 – C. Pic (Caterham)

15 – G. van der Garde (Caterham)

16 – M. Chilton (Marussia)

17 – J. Button (McLaren) – Did Not Finish

18 – D. Ricciardo (Toro Rosso) – Did Not Finish

19 – P. Maldonado (Williams) – Did Not Finish

20 – A. Sutil (Force India) – Did Not Finish

21 – P. Di Resta (Force India) – Did Not Finish

22 – F. Alonso (Ferrari) – Did Not Finish

Monday 18 March 2013

The Aftermath of Melbourne 2013

After each race this year, I plan to look through what has just happened as well as things to look forward to and think about for the coming 2013 season. I’m a massive Formula 1 fan and I watch every race. This season looks to be very exciting but it has a lot to live up to from what we have seen from the last few years in particular.

Tyre Management


Throughout testing, teams and drivers were saying that tyre management, while important, will not be as crucial this year. That could be true later in the season but not in Melbourne. The heavy rain will have cleared any rubber from the track after Q1 so it’s hard to tell at this stage just how much tyre management will be needed in the upcoming races but the standout team for tyre management would have to be Lotus. Kimi Raikkonen not only managed to make a two stop strategy work for him but he did while pushing when needed, especially at the latter stages when Fernando Alonso started to chase. This is a crucial factor for the teams to analyse. The Lotus may not be the quickest car on raw pace but if they can manage their tyres better at every race, the fewer pit stops will pay dividends. The confusing thing was the Raikkonen’s teammate, Romain Grosjean, could not match his pace and he finished much further back.

Mercedes started off on a two stop strategy as well but had to make a third stop later on that dropped Lewis Hamilton out of a podium finish. It seemed, at first, like they could emulate the Lotus and survive on two stops but it was not to be. Nevertheless, it is an encouraging sign for the team who did not publicly expect to be competing for those positions at this stage in the season. Whether they were more confident behind closed doors is something I can’t answer.

Ferrari did well with their tyres but still needed three stops and surprisingly, the Red Bull are behind them! On outright pace, the latter is the faster car but come race day, the effect of that pace on the tyres is clear and is something that will be looked at with earnest.

The Ferrari Dynamic


It’s common knowledge that Alonso is the number one for Ferrari. He will get the preferential treatment and it’s a shame that Felipe Massa is his teammate. The man has exceptional skill and the latter half of 2012 showed that he was just as fast as Alonso. You can argue that Alonso is the better driver for his outstanding performance throughout the entire 2012 season but Massa can do well, win races and even a championship one day. The pits stops seemed to come at the wrong time for Massa and you have to wonder if it was engineered that way to get Alonso past him, even at this early stage of the season.

Problems for McLaren


During testing, the McLaren team seemed to be the most open about their car and place in the grid. There is something wrong with the car and it is not working how they expect (and want) it to. It was a risk changing their car so much, considering where they ended the 2012 season but if they can’t solve it within a couple of races, I wouldn’t be surprised to see the return of the 2012 car with a whole array of upgrades. They cannot spend too long deciding what to do about this, as every point counts and the signs of a tight championship are already clear. Ninth place for Jenson Button is small consolation and there will be a lot of work being done back at HQ.

Force India Making Progress


It was a solid race for the Force India team. Sutil’s return to F1 racing has to be considered a success. A different strategy paid off and saw him leading the race for a time before his last pit stop dropped into the lower half of the top ten. A few more laps and there would have been an exciting battle between Paul Di Resta and Sutil for who was going to win that internal race. Sutil clinched it this time but the resumption of a good rivalry will be good to watch throughout the season.

Summary


I do love the race at Melbourne. Part of it is the results of testing, part is the first race of the season and the final part is a great circuit. Some of what we have seen in testing has proven to be correct, and others not so much. There are still some mechanical errors to fix and the weather definitely mixed things up a bit more than usual. Marussia have stepped up from last year and with KERS on their cars, are taking the fight to Caterham and scored an early victory. Both teams are still behind the rest of the field.

Mark Webber is still looking for a podium at his home race and I hope he gets it one day. Mercedes could spring a few surprises but Raikkonen has taken the first victory and if they can continue development with the big teams with bigger budgets, they will once again be right in there in the championship hunt. For McLaren, time is running out and they will have to make a decision about their car in the very near future.

Results


1 – K. Raikkonen (Lotus)

2 – F. Alonso (Ferrari)

3 – S. Vettel (Red Bull)

4 – F. Massa (Ferrari)

5 – L. Hamilton (Mercedes)

6 – M. Webber (Red Bull)

7 – A. Sutil (Force India)

8 – P. Di Resta (Force India)

9 – J. Button (McLaren)

10 – R. Grosjean (Lotus)

11 – S. Perez (McLaren)

12 – J. E. Vergne (Toro Rosso)

13 – E. Gutierrez (Sauber)

14 – V. Bottas (Williams)

15 – J. Bianchi (Marussia)

16 – C. Pic (Caterham)

17 – M. Chilton (Marussia)

18 – G. van der Garde (Caterham)

19 – D. Ricciardo (Toro Rosso) – Did not finish

20 – Nico Rosberg (Mercedes) – Did not finish

21 – P. Maldonado (Williams) – Did not finish

22 – N. Hulkenburg (Sauber) - Did not start